It was disappointment for Newport County as they became the second Welsh side to lose at Wembley this season.
Two second-half goals for the Minstermen, the pre-game favourites, through Matty Blair and Lanre Oyebanjo, were enough to seal the FA Trophy for the Yorkshire club.
But County made the most of their first ever appearance at Wembley, with the majority of the 19,800 crowd members of the Amber Army.
But there were no centenary celebrations in the form of silverware for Justin Edinburgh’s side – who were founded back in 1912 – as York came out on top on what was the 100th match to have been played at the new Wembley to take the trophy back to Bootham Crescent.
Welsh teams have now played at the home of English football on six occasions – with Swansea City’s win over Reading in last season’s Championship play-off final still the only win.
Welsh sides’ record at Wembley:
York City 2-0 Newport County (12 May 2012, FA Trophy final)
Liverpool 2p-2 Cardiff City (26 February 2012, Carling Cup final)
England 1-0 Wales (6 September 2011, European Championship qualifier)
Swansea City 4-2 Reading (30 May 2011, Championship play-off final)
Blackpool 3-2 Cardiff City (22 May 2010, Championship play-off final)
Portsmouth 1-0 Cardiff City (17 May 2008, FA Cup final)